“Once upon a time, there was a little duck. His name was Egbert. And he lived in Edgewood Park …”

With those words of introduction, I knew it was time for a fantasy flight with one of cousin Esther’s made-up mallard stories. My Juvenile Furniture Company-purchased bed suddenly grew wings as I soared above tall, leafy trees, made friends with frogs and turtles or squealed with delight while sliding across the park’s icy pond – no skates necessary. 

At the story’s conclusion, I gave my teddy bear an extra hug and slipped into dreamland.

An escape from reality. Young kids do it all the time.

But as the child of a Holocaust survivor, my realities were … how shall I put it … a bit more graphic. From concealed listening posts – behind a bathtub shower curtain, under a table or in a closet – I unwittingly inhaled the second-hand smoke of my mother’s hush-toned, accented-English descriptions of hell and horror to her new American-born friends. 

A hanging here. A sharp-toothed German Shepherd there. 

Fantasy. I later realized it empowered my mother to have the will to survive. Imagining a joyous, tearful reunion with her family at the war’s conclusion, she forced herself to endure hunger, illness, beatings, whippings and other degradations. It worked. On her day of liberation by the Red Army in 1945, she was 16 years old and weighed less than 70 pounds.

However, reality intervened. Instead, the tears were for pain and unimaginable loss. Of the 91 family members and relatives my mother could name, six survived. Her sister, Manya – Esther’s mother – was one of them. My mother’s realities became mine as well.

As I grew older, cousin Esther replaced Egbert with Archie, Betty, Veronica and Jughead, pathways for my budding adolescent fantasies (I could do without Big Ethel). These comic book characters were likely part of her own way of processing reality with fantasy.

Following the birth of my children and grandchildren, Egbert re-emerged. His stories – soaring in hot air balloons while orbiting the planets, outsmarting sly foxes, adopting a little brother (appropriately named Quack) – were now mine.

 “Once upon a time, there was a little duck. His name was Egbert …”

Through the children’s wide eyes, I saw them painting their own pictures with my words, creating fantasies to help them soar beyond their daily realities. However, with each new Egbert ascension, I also embarked on another chapter in my life-long and perhaps futile journey to escape the frayed but enduring threads of intergenerational Holocaust trauma.

6 thoughts on “Reality and Fantasy: Taking Flight With Egbert

  1. akcpa22@gmail.com Kaplan

    Very moving story. Thanks for sharing!

  2. Benjamin

    I always loved hearing Egbert’s stories. You should tell us other ones sometimes.

    Love,
    Ben

  3. Ben

    Love you Saba! And Don’t Forget Quack, Egbert’s Brother:)

    Love,
    Ben

    1. Arthur

      My dear grandson, Ben!
      You are amazing and – as a little brother myself – I will always remember Quack and assure he has a meaningful voice in my stories.
      Love, Saba

  4. Marilyn Teitelbaum

    You mean you read Archie comic books too? I would have traded with you !!!!!

    1. Arthur

      Don’t forget Richie Rich, the poor little rich boy comic books!

Leave A Comment

Recommended Posts

Blog

A Freedom Trifecta

Partially concealed beneath a pile of beige, tan and taupe nylons, the bright red strip of cloth caught my attention as I rummaged through Sally Finkelstein Horwitz’s bedroom drawer in search of a stray, five-dollar bill that never made it into her wallet. For a twelve-year-old, Honest Abe had real […]

Blog

Does Everyone Still Hate Us?

Driving down Woodward Avenue shortly after arriving in 1986 to publish the Detroit Jewish News, I was greeted near its intersection with 12 Mile Road by a 100-foot limestone tower sculpted with a 28-foot-tall Jesus – the Charity Crucifixion Tower, I would later learn was its name. This was the […]

Elderly Jewish man wearing tefillin during morning prayer
Blog

Answered Prayers

After moving from New Haven, my parents’ initial years in Michigan were mostly golden. “So many Jews! So much food! So many good causes and interesting speakers!” they marveled.  B’nai Moshe in West Bloomfield became their second home, religiously and socially. There, a membership subgroup of Holocaust survivors embraced my […]

Group of Jewish Holocaust survivors and their children gathered at Edgewood Park in New Haven during Rosh Hashanah
Blog

“For You Delight in Love”

Is there any divinity save You who forgives the sins and pardons the transgressions of the remnant, your People? … You will return to us compassionately, overcoming the consequences of our sin, hurling our sins into the depths of the sea. From tashlich prayers The remnant, your People. For New […]

Old memory photo of Elsie, a white horse
Blog

Remembering The First Time 

With tight blue jeans, a white turtleneck sweater, over-the-calf leather boots and a black jumper’s helmet, Becky was an alluring sight as she cantered her horse around the indoor arena of the Yale polo barn.  However, even before reaching puberty, I knew my Holocaust survivor mother’s rules. No Beckys allowed. […]